Model answer & approach
- Mill’s work was crucial to the development of liberalism, because it straddled the divide between classical and modern theories. Analyze. (Answer in 350 words)
Introduction
Mill inherited the utilitarian and laissez-faire creed of Bentham and his father, and left liberalism with a doctrine of individuality, self-development and social reform that classical liberalism could not contain. He is the hinge on which the tradition turns.
Body
1. The classical inheritance: On Liberty (1859) states the harm principle — power may rightfully be exercised over a member of a civilised community against his will only to prevent harm to others — and defends a private sphere immune from law and opinion alike.
2. Freedom of thought at its purest: if all mankind minus one held an opinion, silencing that one would be illegitimate; suppressed truth is lost and unchallenged truth decays into dead dogma.
3. Economic orthodoxy: in the Principles of Political Economy (1848) laissez-faire is the general practice, and every departure from it a certain evil unless required by some great good.
4. The first break, qualitative utility: Utilitarianism (1863) ranks higher above lower pleasures and prefers Socrates dissatisfied to a fool satisfied. Pleasure ceases to be the standard; human development takes its place, and with it a perfectionist warrant for public action.
5. The second break, distribution is social: Mill separated the laws of production, which are natural, from the laws of distribution, which are institutional and alterable. That distinction licenses redistribution, and by Chapters on Socialism (1879) he endorsed worker cooperatives, inheritance taxation and land reform.
6. State duties: compulsory education at public expense, factory regulation, and protection of those who cannot contract freely.
7. Feminism: The Subjection of Women (1869) calls the legal subordination of one sex wrong in itself and marriage a school of despotism, extending liberty into the family that classical liberals left alone.
8. Democracy qualified: Representative Government (1861) values participation for its developmental effect, yet adds plural voting and Hare's proportional representation to protect competence and minorities.
9. The imperial exclusion: despotism remains legitimate for what he calls backward states of society — the flaw Uday Mehta and Bhikhu Parekh place at liberalism's centre.
Conclusion
Mill straddles the divide because his commitment to individuality outgrew the minimal state that was supposed to protect it. Green, Hobhouse and finally Rawls complete the passage he began.
Open this in the study app →