Model answer & approach
- Discuss how national security can be balanced with concerns of human rights. (Answer in 150 words)
Introduction
National security and human rights are not inherently contradictory; durable security depends on protecting citizens while ensuring that state power remains lawful, proportionate and accountable.
Body
Balancing the Two:
1. Rule of Law: Counter-terrorism and security operations must function within constitutional and statutory limits.
2. Proportionality: Restrictions on liberty, surveillance or movement should be necessary, targeted and proportionate to the threat.
3. Due Process: Arrest, detention and investigation must ensure legal safeguards, fair trial and protection against torture.
4. Accountability: Independent judiciary, human rights commissions and legislative oversight should examine misuse of security powers.
5. Professional Security Forces: Human-rights training, body cameras and clear rules of engagement can minimise excesses.
6. Address Root Causes: Development, dialogue, rehabilitation and political inclusion reduce alienation that may fuel extremism.
At the same time, rights cannot become a shield for violence or terrorism; the State has a legitimate duty to protect life and sovereignty.
Conclusion
Thus, national security is strengthened, not weakened, when security measures uphold constitutional morality, dignity, proportionality and accountability.
Open this in the study app →