Model answer & approach
- A business house is working on a project that could displace a forest community from their habitat. As the administrative officer of that district, what ethical challenges are you likely to face? (Answer in 150 words)
Introduction
As district administrator, the central ethical challenge is to balance economic development and public interest with the rights, dignity and livelihood security of the forest community.
Body
Major Ethical Challenges:
1. Development vs Justice: The project may create jobs and infrastructure but impose disproportionate costs on a vulnerable community.
2. Consent and Participation: Ensuring genuine consultation and free, informed participation rather than token hearings.
3. Legal Duty vs Political Pressure: Pressure from business or higher authorities may conflict with obligations under forest and rehabilitation laws.
4. Displacement and Livelihood: Compensation alone may not restore access to forests, culture, community networks and traditional livelihoods.
5. Environmental Responsibility: Ecological damage may create long-term public costs beyond immediate economic gains.
6. Conflict of Interest and Integrity: The officer must resist corruption, lobbying and preferential treatment.
7. Inter-generational Equity: Decisions must consider future ecological and social consequences.
Conclusion
The officer should ensure lawful acquisition, transparent consultation, fair rehabilitation, environmental safeguards and independent monitoring, so that development does not become an instrument of injustice.
Open this in the study app →