Model answer & approach
- Centre-State administrative relations are a matter of debate as constitutional provisions created a strong Centre. Discuss. (Answer in 150 words)
Introduction
The Centre–State administrative relations in India have remained a subject of debate because the Constitution, while federal in form, is unitary in spirit, giving the Union Government predominant authority.
Body
1. Constitutional Basis of Central Dominance:
- Under Articles 256–263, States must comply with Union laws, and the Centre can issue directives to ensure compliance.
- All-India Services (Article 312) and inter-State councils ensure coordination but also strengthen central supervision.
- During national emergencies (Articles 352, 356, 360), the Centre assumes extensive administrative control over States.
- The Governor, appointed by the President, acts as the Union’s representative in States, often leading to friction.
2. The Debate: Critics argue that this asymmetrical structure limits true federal autonomy, while supporters contend it ensures national integrity and administrative uniformity in a diverse country.
Conclusion
Thus, while the Constitution empowers the Centre to maintain unity, achieving balanced cooperative federalism requires respecting the spirit of decentralization and mutual trust between the Union and States.
Open this in the study app →