Model answer & approach
- In what manner is our understanding of serogenetics and cytogenetics useful in reproductive biology? What are the major ethical issues involved in reproductive technology? (Answer in 250 words)
Introduction
Serogenetics and cytogenetics supply reproductive medicine with its two commonest diagnostic frames, antigenic incompatibility and chromosomal error. The technologies built on them raise ethical problems that Indian law addresses only partly.
Body
1. Serogenetics in reproduction: Rh incompatibility, where a D-negative mother carries a D-positive fetus, causes haemolytic disease of the newborn after sensitisation, now prevented by anti-D immunoglobulin and monitored by the indirect Coombs test; ABO incompatibility produces a milder form. HLA sharing has been implicated in recurrent pregnancy loss and pre-eclampsia, and premarital haemoglobin screening for thalassaemia and sickle cell disease turns the same knowledge to prevention.
2. Cytogenetics in reproduction: roughly half of first-trimester losses are chromosomally abnormal, and a balanced translocation in one partner explains a small but significant share of recurrent miscarriage. Karyotyping identifies 45,X in primary amenorrhoea and 47,XXY or Y-microdeletions in azoospermia. Prenatal diagnosis by chorionic villus sampling, amniocentesis, microarray and cell-free fetal DNA, and preimplantation testing of embryos, extend this to selection before birth.
3. The ethical issues: sex-selective abortion, which the PCPNDT Act of 1994 addresses by banning disclosure of fetal sex; selection against disability and the disability rights objection to it; embryo selection sliding towards enhancement and germline editing; commodification of gametes and gestation, regulated by the Surrogacy Regulation Act and the ART Act of 2021; donor anonymity against a child's claim to know its origins; consent and incidental findings; and unequal access to costly technology.
Conclusion
The science is diagnostic; the ethics turn on what is done with a diagnosis. Mandatory counselling before testing, and regulation of what may be selected for, are the workable safeguards.
Open this in the study app →