Model answer & approach
- Health as a cultural construct (Answer in 150 words)
Introduction
Health is not merely the absence of pathology; it is a state defined, recognised and treated within a cultural system. Biomedicine is one such system, not a neutral standard against which others are measured.
Body
1. Illness against disease: Arthur Kleinman separates disease, the biomedical lesion, from illness, the culturally shaped experience of being unwell. Patient and healer each hold explanatory models of cause, course and cure; therapy fails where these diverge.
2. Culture fixes cause, body and cure: the Azande refer misfortune to witchcraft (Evans-Pritchard); Indian humoral reasoning sorts foods and ailments as hot and cold; Ayurvedic tridosha and germ theory are rival nosologies. Zborowski showed that even the expression of pain is learned.
3. What the position enables: it makes comparison possible, explains medical pluralism and non-compliance, and underpins programme design — ORS messaging, DOTS adherence and tribal maternal care work better when routed through local categories and existing healers.
Conclusion
The claim does not deny biology; it insists that biology is always encountered through culture. Health interventions that treat local categories as ignorance to be corrected reliably under-perform.
Open this in the study app →