Model answer & approach
- Critically evaluate India-Russia relations in the 21st century. How have both the countries responded to America meddling in their relations in the recent times. (Answer in 350 words)
Introduction
India-Russia relations this century have been resilient but narrowing. Declared a strategic partnership in October 2000 and made special and privileged in 2010, it now rests on two working pillars — legacy defence and discounted energy — with the political scaffolding under strain.
Body
1. Defence, large but shrinking: Russian equipment remains most of India's existing inventory, yet its share of new imports fell from roughly three-quarters in 2009-13 to about a third in 2020-24. The S-400 contract (2018), Su-30MKI licence production, AK-203 rifles at Korwa and the BrahMos joint venture, exported to the Philippines in 2022, show both the depth and the ceiling.
2. Energy transformed the balance sheet: Russia went from under one per cent of Indian crude imports before 2022 to a peak near forty per cent, alongside Kudankulam with Rosatom and ONGC Videsh stakes in Sakhalin-1 and Vankor.
3. A lopsided trade: bilateral trade crossed 65 billion dollars while Indian exports stayed near five billion, an imbalance and a payments problem that the hundred-billion-dollar target of 2024 does not by itself solve.
4. The China discount: Moscow's dependence on Beijing since February 2022, its warmth towards Pakistan and its criticism of the Indo-Pacific concept reduce the political value India once purchased.
5. American pressure, first phase: CAATSA (2017) threatened sanctions over the S-400 and none followed, and the G7 price cap of December 2022 in practice legalised India's discounted purchases.
6. American pressure, second phase: the additional twenty-five per cent penalty tariff from 27 August 2025, taking total duties to fifty per cent, and the October 2025 designation of Rosneft and Lukoil, tied Indian trade access directly to Indian energy policy.
7. India's response: rejection of extraterritorial sanctions as unjustified and unreasonable, a tactical dip in state refiners' purchases without a policy reversal, faster trade diversification through TEPA (2024) and the UK agreement of July 2025, and the annual summit with President Putin in New Delhi in December 2025.
8. Russia's response: deeper discounts, rupee and dirham settlement, logistics and mobility agreements, and public backing for India against what Moscow calls neo-colonial pressure.
Conclusion
Both capitals treated American pressure as evidence of the partnership's usefulness rather than a reason to abandon it. Its value to India is now insurance — against coercion, and against a Russia wholly inside China's orbit — and its ceiling is set by those same dependencies.
Open this in the study app →