NCERT
Every NCERT book that matters for UPSC — open a book, then a chapter. Learn each chapter's concepts, then how UPSC tests them — with diagrams, flowcharts and the past questions to attempt.
0% read
← Indian Constitution at Work — all chaptersLocal Governments
Start here: why this chapter matters
In simple wordsIf the street light outside your house is broken, you don't write to Parliament. You go to the ward member or the Panchayat. Local government is the government you can actually walk up to.
Chapter 7 divided power between the Union and the States. This chapter adds a third tier: Panchayats in villages and Municipalities in towns. It explains why local bodies matter, how the 73rd and 74th Amendments changed them, and why they are still weaker than the law promises.
- Builds on Chapter 2 (Directive Principles — village panchayats), Chapter 3 (elections and reservations) and Chapter 7 (State subjects, finance commissions).
- Leads to Chapter 9 (amendments) and Chapter 10 (the Constitution as a living document).
- UPSC: GS2 ‘devolution of powers and finances up to local levels and challenges therein’ — a steady Prelims topic since 1979 and a regular Mains question.
| Word | What it means here |
|---|---|
| Local government | Elected government at village, block, district or town level |
| Panchayati Raj Institutions (PRIs) | Rural local bodies: Gram, Block/Mandal and Zilla Panchayats |
| Nagarpalikas | Urban local bodies: Municipal Corporations, Municipalities, Nagar Panchayats |
| Gram Sabha | All adult voters of a Panchayat area |
| Sarpanch / Adhyaksha | Head (chairperson) of a Panchayat |
| Decentralisation | Handing real decision-making power and resources downwards |
| Eleventh / Twelfth Schedule | Lists of functions for Panchayats (29) / Municipalities (18) |
| State Election Commissioner | Independent officer who conducts local elections |
| State Finance Commission | Reviews local bodies' finances every five years |
| PESA | 1996 Act extending Panchayats to Scheduled (Adivasi) Areas |
| Devolution | Constitutional/legal transfer of functions, funds and functionaries (the ‘3 Fs’ — Beyond NCERT) |
Reading the two stories (page 177)
- Geeta Rathore, Jamonia Talab Gram Panchayat, Sehore (Madhya Pradesh): elected Sarpanch in 1995 from a reserved seat and re-elected in 2000 from a non-reserved seat; she renovated tanks, built a school and roads, and fought domestic violence.
- Vengaivasal Gram Panchayat (Kancheepuram, Tamil Nadu): in 1997 it refused to endorse the State's allotment of village land; the Collector acquired it; a single judge of the Madras High Court sided with the Collector, but the Division Bench reversed this, calling the order a gross violation of the Panchayats' constitutional status.
- The point: reservations create leaders, and constitutional status lets a village defend its rights.
- Side cartoon: aren't women Sarpanches sometimes harassed by male members? Yes — reservation opens the door; social change takes longer.
At a glance — the six ideas to carry away
- Local government = government at village and district level; it strengthens participation and accountability.
- Before 1992: State subject + Directive Principle (Art. 40*); Ripon's local boards (1882); Community Development 1952; Panchayati Raj around 1960.
- 73rd (rural) and 74th (urban) Amendments: passed 1992, in force 1993; States had one year to change their laws.
- Three tiers, Gram Sabha, direct elections, five-year term, re-election within six months of dissolution.
- One-third seats for women, SC/ST by population (also chairpersons); OBC optional. 29 subjects (11th Schedule), 18 (12th).
- State Election Commissioner and State Finance Commission (every 5 years); PESA 1996 for Adivasi areas; but powers and money remain limited.
1. Why local governments?
In simple wordsThe person who lives next to the pond knows best when it is drying up. Local government gives that person a say — and a budget.
- Closest to the people: deals with day-to-day problems; approachable quickly and cheaply.
- Local knowledge and interest improve decisions and make administration efficient and people-friendly.
- Participation: ordinary citizens join decisions about their own development (Geeta Rathore).
- Accountability: local bodies can hold higher authorities to account and protect local interests (Vengaivasal).
- Tasks that can be done locally should be left to local people — strengthening local government strengthens democracy.
Reading the side cartoons and ‘Check your progress’ (pages 178–179)
- A girl wonders whether India could have only local governments with a national coordinating body — close to Gandhi's vision of village republics.
- Check your progress: local government strengthens democracy through participation and accountability; Tamil Nadu should have consulted the Gram Panchayat and respected its constitutional role.
- A boy suspects a non-elected panchayat would be dominated by elders, the rich and upper-caste men — which is exactly why elected, reserved seats matter.
2. Growth of local government in India
In simple wordsThe idea is very old; the guarantee is very new. For forty years after independence, a State could simply skip local elections. The 1992 amendments made that impossible.
Self-governing village communities existed as sabhas; later, panchayats (assemblies of five) settled village issues. Elected local bodies — local boards — came after 1882 on the initiative of Viceroy Lord Ripon (NCERT spells it ‘Rippon’). After the Government of India Act 1919, village panchayats were set up in several provinces, a trend that continued after the 1935 Act. Gandhi wanted decentralisation of economic and political power, with village panchayats at the base.
Reading Gandhi's quotation and Ananthasayanam Ayyangar's portrait (pages 180–181)
- Gandhi: independence must begin at the bottom; every village a self-sustained republic; ‘ever-widening, ever-ascending circles’ — a pyramid sustained by its base. The point: power should flow upwards from villages.
- A pen portrait of M. Ananthasayanam Ayyangar with his words in the Constituent Assembly (17 November 1948): villages should be trained in self-government, even autonomy, and reformed with democratic principles.
- A boy asks why village factions are feared when every party — even his class — has factions. Good question: factions are not always bad; domination is the problem.
In the Constitution (1950), local government was given to the States and mentioned in the Directive Principles — non-justiciable and advisory. Why so little importance? (1) Partition produced a unitary inclination; Nehru saw extreme localism as a threat to unity. (2) Dr. Ambedkar and others felt that the faction- and caste-ridden village would defeat local democracy. Yet nobody denied the value of people's participation in planning.
After independence: the Community Development Programme (1952) sought people's participation; a three-tier Panchayati Raj was then recommended; some States (Gujarat, Maharashtra) adopted elected local bodies around 1960. But bodies lacked powers and funds, many States did not set them up, some were dissolved and handed to officers, elections were often indirect or postponed. After 1987 a review began; in 1989 the P.K. Thungon Committee recommended constitutional recognition, periodic elections, and functions with funds.
Beyond NCERT — committees and firsts
- Article 40 (Directive Principle): the State shall organise village panchayats as units of self-government (UPSC 2012 tested this list in Chapter 2).
- Balwant Rai Mehta Committee (1957) recommended the three-tier ‘democratic decentralisation’; Rajasthan launched Panchayati Raj at Nagaur on 2 October 1959, followed by Andhra Pradesh (UPSC 1979, 1981, 1985, 1991, 1998). The Community Development Programme began on 2 October 1952 (UPSC 1981).
- Ashok Mehta Committee (1977–78) suggested two tiers; G.V.K. Rao (1985) and L.M. Singhvi (1986) committees followed, Singhvi urging constitutional status.
- The 64th and 65th Amendment Bills (1989) passed the Lok Sabha but failed in the Rajya Sabha.
- Lord Ripon is called the father of local self-government (UPSC 1983); India's first municipal corporation was Madras (1688) (UPSC 2009).
- Before 1992, Nagaland and Meghalaya had no Panchayati Raj (UPSC 1979, 1986); they remain outside Part IX (Art. 243M).
Reading ‘Check your progress’ and the Brazil box (page 182)
- Did Nehru and Ambedkar object for the same reason? No — Nehru feared localism against national unity; Ambedkar feared caste and faction in villages. Before 1992 the Constitution had only a State subject and a Directive Principle. Gujarat and Maharashtra set up elected bodies around 1960 (Rajasthan and Andhra Pradesh in 1959 — Beyond NCERT).
- Brazil: the constitution creates States, Federal Districts and Municipal Councils with independent powers; just as the Republic cannot interfere with States, States cannot interfere with municipal councils — local government protected by the constitution itself.
3. The 73rd Amendment: Panchayati Raj
In simple wordsBefore 1992, Panchayats were like a cricket club that played only when the State felt like it. The amendment fixed the fixtures: matches every five years, a team list that includes women and Dalits, and an independent umpire.
In 1989 the Union introduced two amendments for uniformity; the 73rd (rural, PRIs) and 74th (urban, Nagarpalikas) were passed in 1992 and came into force in 1993. Local government stays a State subject, but States had to bring their laws into line within one year.
- Three tiers: Gram Panchayat (village or group of villages); intermediate Mandal/Block/Taluka Panchayat (not needed in smaller States); Zilla Panchayat for the whole rural district.
- Gram Sabha is mandatory: all adults registered as voters in the Panchayat area; its role is set by State law.
- Elections: all three levels directly elected; five-year term; if dissolved early, fresh elections within six months. Earlier, district bodies were often indirectly elected and there was no rule for quick elections.
- Reservations: one-third seats for women; SC and ST seats in proportion to population at all levels; OBC reservation if the State wishes; reservations also apply to chairpersons, and women's one-third applies within SC/ST seats too.
- Transfer of subjects: 29 subjects, earlier in the State List, listed in the Eleventh Schedule; actual transfer depends on State law.
- PESA (1996): extends panchayats to Adivasi areas, with stronger Gram Sabhas that protect traditional management of forests and water.
- State Election Commissioner: independent; not under the Election Commission of India. State Finance Commission: every five years, reviews finances and the distribution of revenue between State and local bodies, and between rural and urban bodies.
Reading the side cartoons (pages 183–184)
- A boy finds it funny that the Centre forced decentralisation on the States — ‘decentralisation through a centralised process’. True: it took a constitutional amendment to make States share power.
- A girl asks whether the Gram Sabha really is the forum of the whole village and whether it meets regularly. Often it doesn't — attendance and frequency are weak points.
- Another asks why women's reservation passed easily for local bodies when it was stuck for legislatures. Local seats threatened fewer established politicians (Beyond NCERT: the 106th Amendment, 2023, later provided one-third reservation for women in the Lok Sabha and Assemblies, to take effect after delimitation following the next census).
Reading the Eleventh Schedule extract and the Article 243G box (page 185)
- The box lists sample subjects: agriculture; minor irrigation and watershed development; small-scale industries; rural housing; drinking water; roads; rural electrification; poverty alleviation; education including primary and secondary schools; vocational and adult education; libraries; cultural activities; markets and fairs; health and sanitation; family welfare; women and child development; social welfare; welfare of SC/ST; public distribution.
- Article 243G: the State Legislature may, by law, endow Panchayats with powers over these matters — note the word ‘may’: transfer is not automatic.
- Side cartoon: why only State-List subjects? Because the amendment concerns devolution by States; Union subjects like defence or currency don't suit village-level administration.
⤵ From a constitutional amendment to a working Panchayat
Constitution amended73rd Amendment passed 1992; in force 1993 (24 April 1993 — Beyond NCERT)
State amends its Panchayat lawwithin one year, to match Part IX
State Election Commissioner holds electionsdirect elections at all three tiers, with reserved seats
State law transfers subjects and fundsfrom the 29 in the Eleventh Schedule (Art. 243G); taxes and grants (Art. 243H — Beyond NCERT)
Panchayat plans and implementswith the Gram Sabha; plans are consolidated in the District Planning Committee (Beyond NCERT)
⤵ If a Panchayat is dissolved early (Art. 243E — detail Beyond NCERT)
State dissolves the Panchayatbefore its five-year term ends
Elections within six monthsconducted by the State Election Commission (NCERT)
New Panchayatserves only the remainder of the old five-year term
Less than six months leftno election needed for that short period
Reading the side cartoon and Activity (pages 186–187)
- A boy asks: States are themselves poor and beg from the Centre — how can they fund local bodies? Hence the State Finance Commission, and the Union Finance Commission's duty to suggest ways to augment State funds for local bodies (Art. 280(3) — Beyond NCERT).
- Activity: list powers your State has delegated to panchayats — e.g. drinking water, sanitation, school buildings, rural roads, issuing certificates.
Beyond NCERT — Part IX articles UPSC tests
- Part IX (Arts 243–243O) was inserted by the 73rd Amendment (UPSC 2005); the Eleventh and Twelfth Schedules were added by the 73rd and 74th.
- Art. 243B: intermediate level not compulsory where a State's population does not exceed 20 lakh — so it does not exist in all States (UPSC 2025). Art. 243F: minimum age 21 (not 25 or 30; UPSC 2016, 2025). Art. 243E: a Panchayat reconstituted after premature dissolution continues only for the remainder of the term (UPSC 2016; six months — UPSC 2009).
- Art. 243I: the Governor constitutes the State Finance Commission (not the Chief Minister — UPSC 2025), which recommends principles for taxes, duties and grants for Panchayats (UPSC 2010). Art. 243K: the State Election Commissioner is appointed by the Governor and removable only like a High Court judge.
- Not in the 73rd Amendment: District Planning Committees (they are in Part IXA, Art. 243ZD — UPSC 2011), a two-child norm for members (some State laws have it — UPSC 1997), or regular salaries for members (UPSC 1999).
- Art. 243M: Part IX does not apply to Nagaland, Meghalaya, Mizoram, Scheduled and tribal areas, certain hill areas of Manipur and the Darjeeling hill areas; Parliament extended it to Scheduled Areas through PESA. PESA's objectives include self-governance, recognising traditional rights and freeing tribals from exploitation — not creating autonomous regions (UPSC 2013); its Gram Sabhas can prevent land alienation, own minor forest produce and must be consulted on mining leases (UPSC 2012).
- Art. 243O: courts cannot question delimitation or seat allotment, and elections can be challenged only by election petition.
- OBC reservation: upheld in K. Krishna Murthy v. Union of India (2010) subject to empirical data; Vikas Kishanrao Gawali (2021) required a ‘triple test’ — a dedicated commission, proportion specified, and a 50% overall ceiling.
4. The 74th Amendment: urban local bodies
In simple wordsA town's problems — garbage, drains, slums, traffic — are different from a village's. The 74th Amendment gave towns the same democratic guarantees as villages, with a different list of jobs.
Where does a village end and a town begin? NCERT gives the Census definition: a minimum population of 5,000; at least 75% of male workers in non-agricultural work; and a density of at least 400 persons per sq km. About 31% of Indians lived in urban areas in 2011. The 74th Amendment largely repeats the 73rd for urban areas: direct elections, reservations, transfer of subjects, State Election Commission and State Finance Commission apply to Nagarpalikas, and functions are listed in the Twelfth Schedule.
Beyond NCERT — Part IXA
- Art. 243Q: three types — Nagar Panchayat (area in transition from rural to urban), Municipal Council (smaller urban area), Municipal Corporation (larger urban area) — so UPSC 2005's statement of ‘two types’ was wrong. Powers of Municipalities are in Part IXA (UPSC 2024).
- Twelfth Schedule: 18 functions — e.g. urban planning, regulation of land use, roads and bridges, water supply, public health and sanitation, fire services, urban forestry, slum improvement, urban poverty alleviation, parks, burial grounds, vital statistics, street lighting and public conveniences.
- Ward Committees in municipalities with 3 lakh or more people (Art. 243S); District Planning Committee (Art. 243ZD) consolidates rural and urban plans; Metropolitan Planning Committee (Art. 243ZE) for areas of 10 lakh or more — it is constitutional and drafts the development plan but does not alone implement schemes (UPSC 2011).
- NCERT's Census criteria define ‘census towns’; ‘statutory towns’ are any places with a municipality, corporation or cantonment board.
Reading the side cartoon (page 187)A girl hopes urban local bodies will do something for slum dwellers' housing, or at least toilets. Slum improvement and sanitation are indeed Twelfth Schedule functions (Beyond NCERT) — whether they are funded is another matter.
5. How the amendments have worked
In simple wordsThe law built a new house for local democracy and invited millions in. But the State still holds most of the keys — to the kitchen (money) and the cupboards (functions).
All States passed implementing laws; in the first decade (1994–2004) most held at least two rounds of local elections, and some (Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan) three. NCERT counts more than 600 Zilla Panchayats, about 6,000 intermediate Panchayats and 2,40,000 Gram Panchayats, and over 100 city Corporations, 1,400 town Municipalities and over 2,000 Nagar Panchayats. More than 32 lakh members are elected every five years — at least 13 lakh women — against fewer than 5,000 MPs and MLAs together. (These are NCERT's figures from the mid-2000s, not current counts.)
- Women: at least 200 women Zilla Adhyakshas, 2,000 block presidents, over 80,000 women Sarpanches; over 30 women Mayors, 500 Municipality heads, about 650 Nagar Panchayat heads (NCERT). Women gained confidence and control of resources; ‘proxy’ representation by male relatives exists but is declining.
- SC/ST: SC 16.2% and ST 8.2% of the population (NCERT's census figures; 2011 Census: 16.6% and 8.6% — Beyond NCERT); about 6.6 lakh elected members are from these communities; most States also reserve for backward castes. Social profiles changed — and dominant groups resist, causing tension that is part of deepening democracy.
Reading the flag photograph ‘Read an image’ (page 188)A cloth flag on a bamboo pole carries a hand-written slogan which NCERT renders as ‘We are the government here in the village!’ NCERT: people want genuine implementation, not just formal laws. The point: constitutional status means little unless villagers feel ownership of power.
Reading the newspaper collage (page 189)A full page of Hindi and English clippings: ‘Panchayati raj only in name in Lakshadweep: Minister’ (25 January 2006); a Hindi headline on opposition in Uttaranchal (now Uttarakhand) to a proposed Gram Nyayalaya Bill; a Hindi report of dacoits' influence in Uttar Pradesh zila panchayat elections, with the Governor seeking a report; results of Karnataka zilla panchayat elections where no party won a majority in eleven bodies; and ‘Sarpanches' rally turns violent in Andhra Pradesh’ as Sarpanches demanded the withdrawal of conditions on issuing cheques. The point: local democracy is now real politics — contested, criminalised in places, and fighting State control over money.
Reading the Gram Sabha photograph ‘Read an image’ (page 190)Villagers sit on the ground outside a panchayat building in the sun, men in front and women in the foreground, under a banner in Devanagari script contrasting ‘our government’ in Delhi and Mumbai with the people's own government in the village. NCERT asks what else strikes you: perhaps the seating — who sits in front, who at the back, and whether women speak. The point: participation needs physical and social space, not only a legal right.
6. Limits: powers and money
In simple wordsImagine being elected class monitor but the teacher still decides every rule and keeps the class fund. You have the title, not the power. Many local bodies are in that position.
- Limited autonomy: many States have not transferred most of the 29 subjects; local bodies have little choice of welfare programmes or allocation of resources — so electing so many can become somewhat ‘symbolic’.
- Decision-making at the Centre and in the States has not changed much because of local bodies.
- Money: local bodies have few funds of their own; rural local bodies raise 0.24% of total revenue but account for 4% of government expenditure — dependent on those who give grants.
⤵ How money is meant to reach local bodies (detail Beyond NCERT)
Governor constitutes a State Finance Commissionevery five years (Arts 243I, 243Y)
SFC reviews local financesrecommends sharing of State taxes, taxes local bodies may levy, and grants
Report laid before the State legislaturewith an action-taken memorandum
Union Finance Commission adds supportsuggests measures to augment State funds for Panchayats and Municipalities (Art. 280(3)(bb), (c)), based on SFC reports
Local bodies spend on Eleventh / Twelfth Schedule functionsplus own revenue: property tax, fees, market and fair dues (UPSC 1983, 1991)
Reading the side cartoon and the Bolivia box (pages 191–192)
- A girl: ‘the law is good but mostly on paper — is this the gap between theory and practice?’ Yes; that is NCERT's conclusion too.
- Bolivia: the 1994 Popular Participation Law created 314 municipalities with elected mayors and councils, local elections every five years, responsibility for local health and education facilities, and 20% of national tax collections shared per capita — automatic transfers that India's local bodies lack.
Conclusion (NCERT): local governments still largely implement central and State schemes. Real decentralisation means letting people in villages and towns decide their own policies and programmes. The laws are an important step; the true test of democracy is in their practice.
Precise points
- Women's reservation is one-third (‘not less than one-third’), not 30% (UPSC 1995, 1997). Chairperson posts are reserved too.
- Panchayat elections are now a constitutional mandate conducted by the State Election Commission, not the Election Commission of India (UPSC 2011).
- District Planning Committees and Metropolitan Planning Committees are 74th Amendment (Part IXA) bodies.
- The Gram Sabha consists of voters, not elected members.
- NCERT says the State government ‘appoints’ the State Election Commissioner and the State Finance Commission; formally the Governor does (Arts 243K, 243I).
- Local self-government is best described as democratic decentralisation (UPSC 2017), not federalism — local bodies are not an independent tier in the federal division of powers (UPSC 1995).
NCERT's in-text questions, cartoons and activities — short answers
Why are men unhappy when women assume positions of responsibility? (page 177)
Patriarchal norms and the loss of long-held power; reservation challenges both. Harassment and ‘proxy’ control are real, but experience, training and women's collectives are steadily reducing them.
Could India have only local governments and a national coordinating body? (page 178)
It echoes Gandhi's village republics. But defence, currency, inter-State issues and large-scale planning need strong State and Union governments; the realistic aim is a strong third tier, not replacing the others.
Check your progress: how does local government strengthen democracy; what should Tamil Nadu have done? (page 179)
Participation, accountability, local knowledge, training in self-government. Tamil Nadu should have consulted the Gram Panchayat and Gram Sabha, explained the need, and respected their decision or followed due process.
Wouldn't a non-elected panchayat be dominated by elders, the rich and upper-caste men? (page 179)
Usually, yes — which is why the 73rd Amendment insists on direct elections and reservations for women, SC and ST, including for chairpersons.
Are groups and factions always bad? (page 181)
No — competing groups can represent different interests and keep leaders accountable. They become harmful when they are based on caste domination or violence and block the weaker sections' voice.
Check your progress: did Nehru and Ambedkar have similar objections; what was the pre-1992 provision; which States set up local government in the 1960s–70s? (page 182)
Different: Nehru — localism vs national unity; Ambedkar — caste and faction in villages. Before 1992: a State subject and a Directive Principle (Art. 40). States: Gujarat, Maharashtra (NCERT); Rajasthan, Andhra Pradesh (1959), and later West Bengal, Karnataka (Beyond NCERT).
‘Decentralisation through a centralised process’? (page 183)
Ironically yes — Parliament amended the Constitution to oblige States to decentralise, because left to themselves many States had not. Implementation still depends on State laws.
Does the Gram Sabha really meet regularly? (page 183)
Law requires meetings (frequency set by State law); in practice attendance is often low, especially of women and Dalits, and meetings may be formalities — which is why quorum rules and special women's sabhas have been tried.
Why was women's reservation in local bodies accepted easily but not in legislatures? (page 184)
Local seats threatened fewer sitting politicians, there was broad consensus on grassroots empowerment, and there was no dispute over sub-quotas. (Beyond NCERT: the 106th Amendment, 2023, now provides it for legislatures after the next delimitation.)
Why transfer only State-List subjects? (page 185)
Local government is itself a State subject, and devolution is from the State to its local bodies; Union subjects (defence, foreign affairs, currency) need national uniformity.
States are poor themselves — how can they fund local bodies? (page 186)
Through State Finance Commission devolution, assigned taxes and grants; the Union Finance Commission also recommends direct grants for local bodies (Art. 280(3)); own revenue such as property tax helps.
Activity: powers your State has delegated to panchayats. (page 187)
Typical: drinking water, sanitation, rural roads, primary school buildings, anganwadis, beneficiary selection for housing and pensions, markets and fairs, birth and death registration. Note which come with funds and staff.
Will urban bodies help slum dwellers with housing or toilets? (page 187)
Slum improvement and public conveniences are municipal functions (Twelfth Schedule); results depend on funds, ward committees and pressure from residents.
Read an image: ‘We are the government here in the village!’ (page 188)
It expresses a demand for real power — the Gram Sabha as the primary forum — and a warning that formal laws without functions, funds and functionaries are not enough.
Read an image: the local Sarkar sitting in the sun — what else strikes you? (page 190)
Who is present (men in front, women at the side or back), whether there are chairs, the slogan banner — participation is shaped by gender and caste even when the meeting is open.
‘The law is good but mostly on paper.’ (page 191)
Yes — limited transfer of subjects, dependence on grants and control by officials create a theory–practice gap; the remedy is real devolution of the 3 Fs (functions, funds, functionaries).
NCERT exercise — answer outlines
Try each first, then compare. NCERT has no MCQs here; the self-check below uses the text and Prelims patterns.
Q1. Do these strengthen or weaken panchayats as units of self-government? (a) Gram Sabha demands consultation before a steel plant (b) 20% of all government expenditure through panchayats (c) officials refuse school-building funds because money is tied to schemes (d) village Dungarpur split and merged out of existence (e) panchayat mobilises youth to revive ponds and wells.
(a) Strengthens — Gram Sabha asserting its voice (cf. PESA consent). (b) Strengthens — funds give real power. (c) Weakens — tied funds and officials' control deny local priorities. (d) Weakens — arbitrary redrawing without consultation erases a self-governing unit. (e) Strengthens — local initiative and resource management, self-government in action.
Q2. Five powers you would give village panchayats, with justification.
(1) Plan and spend untied funds — local priorities differ. (2) Manage water, ponds and minor irrigation — they know local resources. (3) Supervise schools and health centres, including staff attendance — accountability of functionaries. (4) Levy and collect local taxes and fees — own revenue reduces dependence. (5) Select beneficiaries and conduct social audits — transparency and fairness. Also: consent over land acquisition and mining (as under PESA).
Q3. Reservation provisions for disadvantaged groups under the 73rd Amendment; effect on village leadership.
SC/ST seats in proportion to population at all levels; one-third of all seats (including within SC/ST seats) for women; chairperson posts reserved likewise; OBC reservation at State option. Effect: lakhs of women, Dalit and Adivasi representatives (NCERT: 6.6 lakh SC/ST members, 80,000+ women Sarpanches); local bodies mirror social reality; new leaders like Geeta Rathore; some proxy rule and resistance from dominant castes.
Q4. Differences in local governments before and after the 73rd Amendment.
Before: optional, varied structures; often indirect elections; postponed elections; supersession by officers; no reservation for women; no fixed functions or finance mechanism. After: uniform three tiers; mandatory Gram Sabha; direct elections every five years and within six months of dissolution; reservations including chairpersons; Eleventh Schedule subjects; independent State Election Commissioner; State Finance Commission.
Q5. Alok, Neha, Jayesh on women's reservation and budgets — your view in 200 words.
Agree with Alok that reservation gives women a share of power, and with Neha that presence must be matched by gender budgeting — separate allocations for women's needs (water, health, safety). Jayesh's view that a body serving ‘all’ automatically serves women ignores how men dominated panchayats before 1993 and neglected women's priorities. Evidence suggests women leaders invest more in drinking water and sanitation. Conclusion: reservation plus capacity building, women's sabhas and gender budgets.
Q6. Which concerns does the 73rd Amendment address? (a) fear of replacement makes representatives accountable (b) dominant castes and landlords dominate (c) rural illiteracy (d) panchayats need resources and powers.
(a) Yes — regular five-year elections. (b) Yes — reservations for SC/ST and women, including chairpersons. (c) No — it sets no literacy rule (though some States later did); it assumes people can decide their own development. (d) Partly — Eleventh Schedule and State Finance Commission, but actual transfer depends on State law.
Q7. Rank the justifications for local government; which underlay Vengaivasal's decision?
Suggested ranking: (c) people know their needs and should decide collectively — the democratic core; (b) local plans gain acceptability; (a) lower costs through community involvement; (d) difficulty contacting MLAs/MPs. Vengaivasal: chiefly (c) — the village asserted its right to decide the use of its own land, and its constitutional status.
Q8. Which involve decentralisation? (a) holding Gram Panchayat elections (b) villagers deciding useful policies and programmes (c) power to call Gram Sabha meetings (d) Panchayat receiving the BDO's progress report on a State project.
(b) is real decentralisation — decision-making power. (a) and (c) are necessary preconditions but not enough without powers and funds. (d) is mere information-sharing about someone else's decision — deconcentration, not decentralisation.
Q9. Raghavendra's questions on a Gram Sabha to get every child to school: (a) day (b) venue (c) a collector-circular-driven meeting (d) your class as Gram Sabha.
(a) Avoid days that exclude groups: BDO's day suits officials, haat day draws people but keeps traders busy, festivals clash; choose a day agreed by villagers — perhaps an evening convenient to women and labourers. (b) The village school: neutral, relevant, accessible to all castes and genders — unlike a religious place or a caste-segregated locality. (c) Poor participation: a top-down circular dominated; the real issues (dropouts, girls, building, timing) were ignored; women teachers absent. (d) Agenda: survey of out-of-school children, girls' safety and toilets, teacher attendance, mid-day meal; action — committee of parents, door-to-door campaign, demand for funds.
What to remember
Numbers
Lord Ripon's local boardsafter 1882
Community Development Programme1952
Gujarat, Maharashtra elected bodies (NCERT)around 1960
Rajasthan Panchayati Raj (Beyond NCERT)2 October 1959, Nagaur
Thungon Committee (NCERT)1989
73rd and 74th Amendmentspassed 1992; in force 1993
Time for States to amend lawsone year
Term of Panchayat5 years
Re-election after dissolutionwithin 6 months
Women's reservationat least one-third
Eleventh Schedule29 subjects
Twelfth Schedule (Beyond NCERT)18 subjects
PESA1996
State Finance Commissionevery 5 years
Urban definition (Census)5,000 people; 75% male non-farm work; 400 per sq km
Urban population, 2011about 31%
Elected local representatives (NCERT)over 32 lakh; at least 13 lakh women
Rural bodies' revenue vs spending (NCERT)0.24% vs 4%
Minimum age for Panchayat member (Beyond NCERT)21 years
Intermediate tier optional (Beyond NCERT)States with population ≤ 20 lakh
One-liners
- Local government = democratic decentralisation.
- Local government is still a State subject.
- 73rd = Panchayats (Part IX); 74th = Municipalities (Part IXA).
- Gram Sabha = all registered voters of the Panchayat area.
- State Election Commissioner is independent of the Election Commission of India.
- Transfer of Eleventh Schedule subjects depends on State law (‘may’ in Art. 243G).
- PESA gives Gram Sabhas special powers in Scheduled Areas.
- Law good, practice weak: functions, funds, functionaries.
Traps to avoid
- Women's reservation is one-third, not 30% or 50% (50% only under some State laws).
- Minimum age is 21, not 25.
- A Panchayat elected after dissolution serves only the rest of the term.
- District and Metropolitan Planning Committees come from the 74th Amendment, not the 73rd.
- The Governor, not the Chief Minister, constitutes the State Finance Commission.
- The intermediate tier is not required in every State.
- Part IX does not apply to Nagaland, Meghalaya and Mizoram.
- OBC reservation in local bodies is optional for States and must pass the ‘triple test’.
- Art. 243Q provides three kinds of urban bodies, not two.
- PESA does not create autonomous regions — that is the Sixth Schedule.
How to strategise
Prelims — what UPSC asks
- History and purpose: aims of Panchayati Raj (1979, 1982, 1984, 2015), democratic decentralisation (2017; A–R 1990), three tiers (1979, 1996), 1959 and Rajasthan/Andhra (1981, 1985, 1991, 1998), Community Development (1981, 2000), Ripon (1983), no PRIs in Nagaland/Meghalaya (1979, 1986), local bodies in States (2000), first corporation (2009).
- 73rd/74th provisions: 73rd's purpose (2000), what it did not provide (1995, 1997, 1999, 2011), Parts IX/IXA (2005, 2024), elections (1990, 1991, 2009), age and term (2016), intermediate level, age and SFC (2025), SFC role (2010), Metropolitan Planning Committee (2011), PESA (2012, 2013).
- Finance: panchayat revenue sources (1983, 1991) and the 13th Finance Commission's grants to local bodies (2012).
Mains — where it appears and how to answer
- GS2 — effectiveness: Panchayats as political rather than governance institutions (2015), local self-government not effective (2017), decentralisation and the grassroots (2022), local bodies and good governance, rural–urban merger (2024).
- GS2 — finances and urban bodies: 13th Finance Commission and local finances (2013), Panchayat financing beyond grants (2018), States reluctant to empower urban local bodies (2023).
- GS2 — social change: women's reservation and patriarchy (2019).
- Answer frame: constitutional design (Parts IX/IXA, schedules, SEC, SFC) → achievements (representation of women, SC/ST; regular elections) → gaps (3 Fs, Gram Sabha weakness, proxy rule, State control, parastatals in cities) → reforms (activity mapping, untied grants, own revenue, capacity building, social audit) → Gandhi's ‘ever-widening circles’.
Self-check
Tap an option. NCERT's own exercise questions come first; the rest test the figures and common confusions.
1. Who took the initiative to create elected local boards in India after 1882?
2. The 73rd and 74th Amendments came into force in:
3. The Gram Sabha consists of:
4. If a Panchayat is dissolved before its term ends, elections must be held within:
5. How many subjects are listed in the Eleventh Schedule?
6. Panchayat elections are conducted by:
7. The 1996 Act extending Panchayats to Adivasi areas mainly:
8. Which body reviews the financial position of local governments every five years?
UPSC questions from this chapter
Open any question to attempt it in the Question bank — your attempt is saved to your progress.